MLB

Blue Jays VS Yankees Best Player Prop Bets

Blue Jays VS Yankees Player Prop Bets - September 20th


Blue Jays VS Yankees Player Prop Bets

Hot off the heels of a thrilling series opening contest, the Toronto Blue Jays will look to continue making their final push toward the postseason as they take on the New York Yankees on the road.

With both sides sporting star-studded lineups, why not raise the stakes of this evening’s action by placing a player prop bet on the Blue Jays VS Yankees?

At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide expert insight and analysis on the MLB so you can load up your bet slip with winning ammunition as you fire off moneymaking bets on the Blue Jays VS Yankees. Below we’ve provided you with the best player prop bets available on tonight’s matchup that are sure to have your bankroll booming by the culmination of the upcoming tilt.

If you’re new to sports betting but want to get some skin in on the game tonight, be sure to check out our in-depth reviews of the best sports betting sites in Canada.

After carefully vetting each of the top Ontario sportsbooks on the market, we’ve compiled the best Canadian bookmakers into one spot so you can easily find a trusted and reliable oddsmaker to bet with this evening.

Check out our top MLB sportsbook reviews, sign up using the links provided, and score your first big win with our Blue Jays VS Yankees player prop bets.



Bo Bichette Over 1.5 Total Bases (+120)


After crushing a huge home run in last night’s matchup with the Yankees, look for Blue Jays shortstop Bo Bichette to record Over 1.5 total bases in this evening’s clash.

Beginning to find his game offensively again, Bichette is a dangerous threat when he steps up to bat. Able to pinpoint the weak spot in opposing defences with ease, look for Bichette to pick his spot wisely, exposing the gap in the oppositions game plan, and capitalizing off of it.

Bet the Over on Bichettes total base tally and watch as he provides his squad with some much-needed offence at a crucial point in the season, scoring you an easy plus-money win on your Blue Jays VS Yankees bet slip.

Aaron Judge Over 0.5 Home Runs (+235)


Easily one of the top power hitters that the MLB has ever seen, look for superstar right fielder Aaron Judge to go yard against the Jays this evening, hitting his 33rd home run of the 2023 season.

Having failed to knock one out of the park in his last four games, it’s only a matter of time before the heavy-hitter finds the target and sends an oncoming pitch into orbit. Judge has had plenty of success hitting the ball against the Jays this season, having racked up four home runs in eight games played head-to-head.

Bank on Judge to demonstrate why he’s still the most-dangerous home run threat in the league, putting his team on the board as he crushes a home run against the Blue Jays this evening.



Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Over 0.5 RBIs (+165)


A force to be reckoned with when he steps up to the plate, look for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to put his team on the scoreboard as he records Over 0.5 RBIs this evening.

Leading the clubhouse in RBIs by a wide margin, Guerrero Jr. has found ample success in providing scoring chances for his team. With six RBIs in his last five games played, look for Guerrero Jr. to continue his hot streak as he knabs you an easy payday with this plus-money pick.

Gleyber Torres Over 0.5 Hits (-245)


Coming off of a two-hit performance against the Blue Jays yesterday evening, look for Yankees second baseman Gleyber Torres to pick up Over 0.5 hits in tonight’s duel.

A reliable offensive contributor for the Yankees, Torres excels at getting on-base. Currently rocking a .400 OBP in the month of September, look for Torres to continue his consistent play as he connects with a pitch at some point in his upcoming game.

With hits in six of his last eight games, expect this trend to continue tonight as Torres finds the mark, recording a hit against the Jays, and securing you an easy payday with this player prop bet.



Kevin Gausman Over 7.5 Strikeouts (-115)


Having played sensationally against the Yankees in 2023, expect another strong performance out of Blue Jays ace, Kevin Gausman this evening.

After recording double-digit strikeouts in both of his starts made against the Yankees this season, Gausman has seemingly cracked the code in his opponents game plan. As the current leader in the American League in total strikeouts this season, expect a healthy amount of fastballs from Gausman this evening as he piles up Ks in the process.

Hammer the Over on Gausman’s strikeout total against the Yankees and watch as your account balance rises alongside his strikeout total.

Michael King Over 3.5 Hits Allowed (-150)


Hoping to make his presence felt in tonight’s clash, look for newly appointed Yankees starting pitcher Michael King to struggle against the Jays, allowing Over 3.5 hits in tonight’s fray.

Having allowed Over 3.5 hits in three-consecutive games played, look for this trend to continue as he goes toe-to-toe with a Jays team that currently sits 7th in the MLB in total hits per game.

While he’s not known for long outings at the bump, expect the Jays to do some damage while King is on the mound as he allows Over 3.5 hits in just his 7th start of the season.

Want more MLB betting news? At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with the best bets and sports gambling advice on all the biggest games and events.

Follow us on Twitter @cdnbetting and TikTok @canadiansportsbetting for exclusive picks you won’t find anywhere else.


Matt Eichhorn

Matt Eichhorn

Having worked in the Sports Gambling industry since 2020, Eichhorn has expertise in all things sports betting. With experience covering various major North American sports leagues he has a wide array of knowledge to draw from when crafting his work.