Blue Jays VS Yankees Picks, Predictions, & Odds

Blue Jays VS Yankees Best Bets - September 19th

Blue Jays VS Yankees Betting Preview

After clawing their way back into a prime spot in the American League Wild Card race, the Toronto Blue Jays currently sit with a one-game lead over the Texas Rangers and Seattle Mariners as we approach the final dozen games of the 2023 regular season.

Needing every win they can muster to punch their ticket to the postseason, the Blue Jays will have a tough test ahead of them as they take on the New York Yankees in a three-game road series.

With so much on the line entering into this series opening contest, why not raise the stakes even higher by placing a bet on the Blue Jays VS Yankees?

At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide expert insight and analysis on the MLB so you can find the top moneymaking picks and predictions with ease. Along with our Blue Jays VS Yankees best bets, we also supply you with helpful betting resources that can elevate your winning potential on your bets placed this evening.

If you’re new to sports betting and are looking to get some skin in on the game, be sure to check out our in-depth reviews on the best sports betting sites in Canada.

After carefully vetting each of the top Ontario sportsbooks on the market, we’ve compiled the best MLB betting sites into one spot so you can easily find the oddsmaker that’s right for you. Sign up using the links provided on-site and get ready to score your first winning wager with our Blue Jays VS Yankees picks, predictions, and odds.

Blue Jays VS Yankees Odds

Toronto Blue Jays-115(-1.5) +145(O 8.5) -118
New York Yankees-105(+1.5) -175(U 8.5) -102

(Odds Courtesy of DraftKings Ontario as of September 19th, 2023)

Blue Jays VS Yankees Picks & Predictions

Moneyline Pick: Toronto Blue Jays

Needing to continue their winning ways to keep their playoff hopes alive, look for the Blue Jays to play with a sense of urgency, giving them the winning edge against the Yankees.

With the Yankees currently sitting six games back of the Wild Card with only 12 games remaining in their 2023 campaign, it’d take a miracle for them to play meaningful baseball at this point in the season.

With simply more to live for, expect the Jays to play with a tremendous amount of effort and intensity as they look to freeze the hot streak of their divisional rivals.

Back the Blue Jays to take the win this evening, continuing to secure their spot in the 2023 MLB playoffs, and netting you a solid payday in the process.

Runline Pick: New York Yankees (+1.5)

Coming into tonight’s clash having won six of their last eight games, look for the surging Yankees to put up a strong fight against the Jays this evening, covering the runline as underdogs in tonight’s matchup.

In head-to-head competition this season the Blue Jays and Yankees have had several close contests with the Yanks taking the win in four of their seven meetings, entering as underdogs in three of those games.

Set to welcome the Jays into a hostile environment, look for the Yankees to utilize their top-end talent, generating dangerous scoring chances routinely, while keeping themselves within striking distance of the lead all game long.

Bank on the Yankees to cover the runline against the Jays in tonight’s tilt and score an easy win on your MLB bet slip with this game line pick.

Over/Under Pick: Under 8.5 Runs

Look for runs scored to come at a premium in tonight’s AL East showdown as the Blue Jays and Yankees combine for Under 8.5 total runs.

With only two of their seven games played against each other having resulted in Over 8.5 total runs, look for this low-scoring trend to continue as these stellar defensive squads shutdown the majority of scoring chances generated this evening.

While both sides possess tremendous offensive potential, neither squad has sported a reliable scoring effort this year. Both the Blue Jays and Yankees come into tonight’s fray ranking in the bottom-half of the league in runs scored per game.

Don’t expect to see a shootout in tonight’s clash, instead a closely contested battle where each run scored could prove to be the winning difference. Hammer the Under on the Blue Jays VS Yankees and watch as your bankroll rises while the scoreboard stays stagnant.

Blue Jays VS Yankees Batter Prop Bets

Bo Bichette Over 1.5 Total Bases (+110)

While he’s certainly cooled down a touch since returning to the Jays lineup after suffering a knee and quad injuries this season, look for Bichette to step up in a big way when his team needs him most, racking up Over 1.5 total bases against the Yankees.

One of the most-skilled precision hitters in baseball, Bichette has never seen a pitch he didn’t like. Able to make contact with seemingly any pitch sent his way, Bichette is always a threat to get on-base and generate offence for his club.

Facing a Yankees squad that he has performed well against in the past this season, look for Bichette to get back on track this evening, tallying Over 1.5 total bases for a +110 boost to your bankroll.

Aaron Judge Over 0.5 RBIs (+135)

One of the most-feared batters in the MLB, look for the Yankees home run slugger, Aaron Judge to produce a scoring play this evening, recording Over 0.5 RBIs against the Blue Jays.

Having blasted four home runs as well as seven RBIs in seven games played against his division rival, Judge is set for another huge outing in tonight’s contest.

Back Judge to leave his mark on tonight’s contest as he produces a scoring play for his team, leaving you with a winning player prop bet on your MLB picks this evening.

Best Blue Jays VS Yankees Pitcher Props

Yusei Kikuchi Over 5.5 Strikeouts (-135)

Coming off of a rough outing against the Rangers his last time out, look for Jays starting pitcher Yusei Kikuchi to get back on track this evening as he records Over 5.5 strikeouts against the Yankees.

Kikuchi has at times been one of the best pitching options for the Jays this season, bu has struggled to maintain consistency. While his overall play has been up-and-down in 2023, his strikeout numbers have largely remained the same.

Averaging 5.62 Ks per game this year, Kikuchi is always in-play to record Over his projected strikeout total. Having racked up Over 5.5 strikeouts in six of his last seven starts, bank on him to find his rhythm early on in tonight’s matchup, piling up Ks in no time against the Yankees.

Clarke Schmidt Over 4.5 Hits Allowed (-130)

Experiencing a turbulent finish to his 2023 regular season, look for Yankees starting pitcher Clarke Schmidt to struggle keeping the batters of the Blue Jays off the board as he allows Over 4.5 hits this evening.

Having allowed Over 4.5 hits in four-straight games, look for this streak to extend into tonight’s matchup as he fails to keep the Jays batters at-bay. With none of his pitches seeming to generate results, expect another lousy showing from Schmidt in tonight’s tilt as he allows Over 4.5 hits.

Looking for additional insight ahead of tonight’s Blue Jays VS Yankees matchup? Then be sure to check out the latest public betting trends available on tonight’s clash.

Below we’ve compiled the latest Blue Jays VS Yankees public betting trends so you can see exactly how other bettors are wagering on tonight’s action. By seeing where the popular money resides, bettors can use this information to help decide how they’d like to bet on the game in question.

Utilize the helpful betting trends found below and decide whether you are going to fade the public or ride with them, thanks to the latest Blue Jays VS Yankees public betting trends.

Toronto Blue Jays - 51%

New York Yankees - 49%

Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5) - 41%

New York Yankees (+1.5) - 59%

Over 8.5 Runs - 27%

Under 8.5 Runs - 73%

Best Odds & Lines on the Blue Jays VS Yankees

Looking to score the best bang for your buck on the Blue Jays VS Yankees? Then make sure to place your next bet with the top online sportsbook offering the best odds & lines on tonight’s tilt.

After scouring the market for the most-profitable odds available, we’ve compiled where you can secure the biggest payout possible on the major betting markets surrounding tonight’s matchup.

Simply find the betting market you wish to wager, follow our direct link to the applicable oddsmaker, sign up, and throw down your next bet with maximized winning potential on the Blue Jays VS Yankees.

Best Moneyline Odds

Toronto Blue Jays - FanDuel (-104)

New York Yankees - BetMGM (-105)

Best Runline Odds

Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5) - FanDuel (+150)

New York Yankees (+1.5) - Bet365 (-170)

Best Run Total Odds

Over 8.5 Runs - DraftKings (-105)

Under 8.5 Runs - BetRivers (-105)

Want more MLB betting news? At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with the best bets and sports gambling advice on all the biggest games and events.

Follow us on Twitter @cdnbetting and TikTok @canadiansportsbetting for exclusive picks you won’t find anywhere else.

Matt Eichhorn

Matt Eichhorn

Having worked in the Sports Gambling industry since 2020, Eichhorn has expertise in all things sports betting. With experience covering various major North American sports leagues he has a wide array of knowledge to draw from when crafting his work.