Yankees VS Blue Jays Picks, Predictions, & Odds

Yankees VS Blue Jays Best Bets - September 26th

Yankees VS Blue Jays Betting Preview

Set to kickoff their penultimate series of the 2023 season, the Toronto Blue Jays will look to make their final push toward the MLB playoffs as they play host to the New York Yankees. Having bested them two games out of three in last weeks series, both sides will be looking to finish the year off with bragging rights within this bitter rivalry.

With the intensity level of this matchup steadily rising, why not raise the stakes even higher by placing a bet on the Yankees VS Blue Jays?

At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with all of the best bets on the Yankees VS Blue Jays so you can stuff your bet slip full of winning wagers on tonight’s action. Along with our expert insight and analysis on the MLB, you can also take advantage of our helpful betting resources supplied below.

If you’re interested in placing a bet on the Yankees VS Blue Jays but aren’t sure where to get started, check out our in-depth reviews on the best sports betting sites in Canada to place your bets with.

After heavily vetting each of the top Ontario sportsbooks on the market, we’ve compiled the best bookmakers in Canada into one place so you can easily find a trusted and reliable oddsmaker to take your action too.

Find the MLB sportsbook that’s right for you, sign up using the links provided, and place your first winning wager with our Yankees VS Blue Jays picks, predictions, and odds.

Yankees VS Blue Jays Odds

New York Yankees+136(+1.5) -162(O 7) -118
Toronto Blue Jays-162(-1.5) +136(U 7) -102

(Odds Courtesy of DraftKings Ontario as of September 26th, 2023)

Yankees VS Blue Jays Picks & Predictions

Moneyline Pick/Runline Pick: Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5)

Set to kickoff their three-game homestand against the Yankees with a win, back the Blue Jays to best their divisional foes, covering the runline as favourites this evening.

After winning four of their last six games, including two against the Yankees, the Blue Jays have seemingly begun to hit their stride at the perfect time in the season. As the Jays continue to aggressively push toward a playoff birth, look for them to shellack a Yankees team with nothing left to play for.

Back the Blue Jays to command the lead from start-to-finish, running up the score as they defeat the Yankees, covering the runline in the process as you net your latest MLB payday.

Over/Under Pick: Over 7 Runs

While the Yankees and Blue Jays haven’t been known for their scoring ability this season, expect the Over to hit in tonight’s tilt as they combine for Over 7 total runs.

In their recent three-game series, each of those contests finished with Over 7 runs scored. With the Blue Jays offence finally in full stride, look for them to keep their foot on the gas as they rack up runs against the Yankees.

With the line set incredibly low, hammer the Over on tonight’s action and watch as you bankroll rises alongside the box score in the Yankees VS Blue Jays.

Yankees VS Blue Jays Batter Prop Bets

Aaron Judge Over 1.5 Total Bases (+115)

One of the most-feared batters in the Major Leagues, expect to see a strong output from Yankees slugger Aaron Judge as he tallies Over 1.5 total bases against the Blue Jays this evening.

In his 10 appearances against the Blue Jays in 2023, Judge has racked up a sensational 25 total bases. Able to dole out damage with his home run power as well as his pinpoint precision, Judge can hurt the Jays in a number of ways.

Look for him to provide his team with some much-needed offence, finishing the game with Over 1.5 total bases, and earning you a juicy +115 payday with this player prop bet.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Over 0.5 RBIs (+160)

Having found no shortage of success against the Yankees in 2023, look for Blue Jays All-Star first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to record Over 0.5 RBIs in tonight’s tilt.

Coming off of back-to-back outings with an RBI against the Tampa Bay Rays, Guerrero Jr. has been sensational at helping his team put up runs on the scoreboard. With eight RBIs in eight games played against the Yankees this season, Guerrero Jr. is a great bet to help put his team ahead in this evening’s showdown.

Bank on Guerrero Jr. to record Over 0.5 RBIs as he gets his team on the scoreboard, continuing his run of dominance against the Yankees in 2023.

Best Yankees VS Blue Jays Pitcher Props

Michael King Under 1.5 Walks (+120)

Having caught fire late in the 2023 season, Yankees starting pitcher Michael King is set to put forth another strong showing as he finishes tonight’s contest with Under 1.5 walks allowed.

Having made the most of his opportunity to showcase his talents as a starter after spending most of the season as a relief option, King has performed wonderfully down the stretch of the season.

Keeping his stat sheet clean, King hasn’t allowed Over 1.5 walks in five-consecutive matchups, including zero walks against the Blue Jays in his last start.

Look for this trend to continue as he feeds the Jays a healthy diet of sinkers and sweepers in order to gain the upper hand this evening, keeping his walk total low, and scoring you a plus-money win when you bet the Under on his total walks allowed.

Kevin Gausman Over 7.5 Strikeouts (-120)

Having dominated the Yankees in head-to-head competition in 2023, Blue Jays ace Kevin Gausman is poised for another stellar showing as he racks up Ks, striking out Over 7.5 batters this evening.

With double-digit strikeouts in each of his three games played against the Yankees this season, don’t expect to see this trend come to an end as Gausman continues to pack heat into each pitch sent towards opposing batters.

Always a great bet to exceed his projected line in total strikeouts, look for Gausman to continue his phenomenal 2023 campaign, helping propel the Blue Jays closer to clinching a postseason spot thanks to his superb fastball.

A great way to gain additional insight prior to the first pitch, MLB public betting trends can provide you with helpful information when creating your next bet slip on the Yankees VS Blue Jays.

The latest Yankees VS Blue Jays public betting trends provides you with information regarding where the majority of bets are being placed on tonight’s matchup. By seeing where the popular money resides, bettors can formulate their next bet slip using the betting behaviour of the public to influence their own picks.

Check out the latest Yankees VS Blue Jays public betting trends below, factor in how others are betting on tonight’s matchup, and score your next big win whether you have to fade the public or ride with them.

New York Yankees - 18%

Toronto Blue Jays - 82%

New York Yankees - 16%

Toronto Blue Jays - 84%

Over 7 Runs - 89%

Under 7 Runs - 11%

Best Odds & Lines on the Yankees VS Blue Jays

Looking to score the best bang for your buck on all your MLB bets placed this evening? Then make sure you’re throwing down your wagers with the top online sportsbook offering the best value on the Yankees VS Blue Jays.

Below we’ve compiled the best odds & lines on the Yankees VS Blue Jays so you can score the biggest possible payout on tonight’s action. Find the betting market you want to wager on below, follow our direct link to the applicable oddsmaker, sign up, and place your next bet with maximized winning potential.

Best Moneyline Odds

New York Yankees - FanDuel (+142)

Toronto Blue Jays - BetMGM (-160)

Best Runline Odds

New York Yankees (+1.5) - FanDuel (-156)

Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5) - BetRivers (+143)

Best Run Total Odds

Over 7 Runs - BetRivers (+105)

Under 7 Runs - Bet365 (+100)

Want more MLB betting news? At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with the best bets and sports gambling advice on all the biggest games and events.

Follow us on Twitter @cdnbetting and TikTok @canadiansportsbetting for exclusive picks you won’t find anywhere else.

Matt Eichhorn

Matt Eichhorn

Having worked in the Sports Gambling industry since 2020, Eichhorn has expertise in all things sports betting. With experience covering various major North American sports leagues he has a wide array of knowledge to draw from when crafting his work.