Yankees VS Blue Jays Picks, Predictions, & Odds

Find the Best Bets Available on the Yankees VS Blue Jays Matchup

Toronto Blue Jays VS New York Yankees Betting Preview

Hot off the heels of a successful weekend homestand against the National League leading Atlanta Braves, the Toronto Blue Jays now direct their sights to an old foe in the New York Yankees. The Blue Jays and Yankees have had plenty of heated battles in the past so don’t expect either side to take tonight’s matchup lightly.

Amidst this evening’s AL East grudge match, why not take the intensity level to new heights by throwing down a bet on the Yankees VS Blue Jays?

At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with the best picks & predictions on the Yankees VS Blue Jays that will have your bankroll booming by the end of tonight’s matchup. Below you can find our top moneymaking bets, expert analysis, and helpful betting resources to take your MLB betting skillset to the next level.

Not only do we provide the top picks for the Yankees VS Blue Jays, but we also supply our readers with the best online sports betting sites in Canada. After carefully reviewing and vetting all of the top MLB sportsbooks on the market, we’ve compiled our complete rankings of the best online betting sites in Ontario.

Check our our in-depth sportsbook reviews, find the online bookmaker that’s right for you, sign up using the links provided on-site, and place your first winning wager with our Yankees VS Blue Jays picks & predictions.

Yankees VS Blue Jays Odds

New York Yankees+145(+1.5) -145(O 9.5) -105
Toronto Blue Jays-170(-1.5) +120(U 9.5) -115

(Odds Courtesy of DraftKings Sportsbook Ontario as of May 15th, 2023)

Yankees VS Blue Jays Best Bets

Moneyline Pick: Toronto Blue Jays

Primed to continue their recent surge in success, back the Blue Jays to defend home turf against the Yankees in tonight’s contest.

With the Yankees currently nipping at the heels of the Blue Jays in the AL East standings, this season series could prove pivotal down the stretch of the season as these talented teams make a push toward the postseason.

While the Yankees have shown they have tremendous upside this year, the Blue Jays depth is something the Yankees will not be able to compete with. Sporting sensational talent at virtually every position on the field, watch as the Yankees struggle to produce offensively and are truly tested defensively as they head for a collision course with the hot bats of the Blue Jays.

So far this season the Yankees have performed poorly as the underdog, only winning in three instances in 11 outings as an underdog. Facing a Blue Jays squad that has consistently produced victories as the favoured team, bank on the Blue Jays to handle business at home, creating more space between themselves and the Yankees as they cruise to a moneyline win this evening.

Runline Pick: New York Yankees (+1.5)

While the Blue Jays are our pick to take the win in tonight’s showdown, don’t expect to see the Yankees simply roll over for their opponents. A fierce squad that is capable of popping off for a dominant performance at any given time, back the Yankees to cover the runline against the Blue Jays.

In their last three matchups, the Yankees took on the Tampa Bay Rays, resulting in them winning outright or covering the +1.5 spread in each matchup. This clearly showcases their ability to keep things close against tough opponents, even with the odds stacked against them.

As mentioned above, the Yankees have struggled to produce wins as the underdog this season, but they have been rock solid at covering the runline. Having covered in six of their 11 games as the underdog, look for the Yankees to continue building upon their strong covering percentage, staying within 1.5 runs of the Blue Jays in tonight’s duel.

Over/Under: Under 9.5 Runs

Many MLB bettors would look at tonight’s matchup as a great shot at capitalizing on two hot offensive teams, but don’t expect to see a high-scoring slugfest as the Yankees and Blue Jays combine for Under 9.5 runs.

Both sides are highly regarded for their offensive productivity, but in a head-to-head matchup, the Under is a great look for the Yankees VS Blue Jays. The Jays have been up-and-down in their scoring this season, either producing for big scoring figures or being held to a low final total.

Meanwhile, the Yankees have quietly looked like a defensive squad this season, straying for their high-octane output from a season ago, now focusing on keeping mistakes to a minimum and playing sound baseball.

Look for these two heavy-hitters to play it safe early on into this matchup, taking the first few innings to initiate a feeling out process, resulting in higher scoring games as this series progresses. Bet the Under on the Yankees VS Blue Jays this evening and watch as your account balance rises while the score stays low.

Best Yankees VS Blue Jays Batter Prop Bets

Anthony Rizzo Over 0.5 Hits

After putting up impressive hitting numbers against the Rays this past week, look for Yankees first baseman, Anthony Rizzo to make contact and get on-base as he records a hit against the Blue Jays this evening.

Having a terrific season at the plate in 2023, Rizzo has has no trouble piling up hits when it’s his turn in the batting order. Averaging 1.7 hits per game in the last seven days, back Rizzo to continue building upon his recent success batting, registering a hit against the Blue Jays in tonight’s battle.

Bo Bichette Over 1.5 Total Bases

He may not have produced at his typical rate this weekend against the Braves, look for Blue Jays shortstop, Bo Bichette to bounce back in a big way in tonight’s matchup with the Yankees. While Bichette was able to rack up two hits in one of their matchups in this weekends three-game series, he was unable to produce in the other two tilts.

Having now conceded the league lead in total bases after his slow play this weekend, look for Bichette to come out guns blazing against the Yankees. Expect to see him making big play after big play at the plate, racking up bases en route to knabbing you a sizeable payday with this wining player prop bet.

Yankees VS Blue Jays Starting Pitcher Props

Jimmy Cordero

Alek Manoah Under 4.5 Strikeouts

Still trying to find his footing this season, all bettors should be hesitant when betting on Alek Manoah’s production. Not looking like the All-Star from a season ago, Manoah has been inconsistent in his starts this year.

Facing a tough Yankees squad that can catch fire quickly hitting the ball, fade Manoah’s strikeout total as he has a difficult time beating the top batters of his opposition. Bet the Under on Manoah’s strikeout line and win big off of his lacklustre play.

If you’re looking to get some skin in on tonight’s action but aren’t sure where you want to lean in the matchup, be sure to check out the latest Yankees VS Blue Jays public betting trends. MLB public betting trends is a helpful betting resource that provides bettors with up to date information regarding how the majority of bettors are placing wagers on tonight’s matchup.

By seeing where the popular money resides, bettors can use this info to help influence their own bet slips this evening. Whether you decide the fade the public or ride with them, be sure to check out the latest Yankees VS Blue Jays public betting trends prior to placing any bets this evening.

New York Yankees - 39%

Toronto Blue Jays - 61%

New York Yankees (+1.5) - 56%

Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5) - 44%

Over 9.5 - 52%

Under 9.5 - 48%

Best Odds & Lines on the Yankees VS Blue Jays

Looking to score the best bang for your buck your Yankees VS Blue Jays bets? Then make sure you’re placing your wagers with the top online sportsbook offering the best odds & lines available on tonight’s action.

Below we’ve compiled the best odds & lines on the Yankees VS Blue Jays so you can get the best value on each of your wagers placed.

Simply find the betting market you’re interested in betting on, follow our direct links to the applicable sportsbook offering the best odds, sign up, and throw down your first wager with maximized winning potential on the Yankees VS Blue Jays.

Best Moneyline Odds

New York Yankees - BetRivers (+143)

Toronto Blue Jays - Bet365 (-160)

Best Runline Odds

New York Yankees (+1.5) - DraftKings (-140)

Toronto Blue Jays (-1.5) - Bet365 (+125)

Best Goal Total Odds

Over 9.5 - BetMGM (+100)

Under 9.5 - FanDuel (+100)

Want more MLB betting news? At Canadian Sports Betting, we provide you with the best bets and sports gambling advice on all the biggest games and events.

Follow us on Twitter @cdnbetting and TikTok @canadiansportsbetting for exclusive picks you won’t find anywhere else.

Matt Eichhorn

Matt Eichhorn

Having worked in the Sports Gambling industry since 2020, Eichhorn has expertise in all things sports betting. With experience covering various major North American sports leagues he has a wide array of knowledge to draw from when crafting his work.